<^-r  “H.l/.Gaw 

DM- 


i  i-'Vv' 


£#Ci£7u 

A*'  l 

[I 


- 


Comparative  Exhibition 


OF 


anxa 

88-B 

32863 


NATIVE  AND  FOREIGN 
ART 


190+ 


If 


/ 


m 


From  November  15th 
to  December  1  ith, 
1904.  215  West 

57th  St,,  New  York 


Digitized  by  the  Internet  Archive 
in  2018  with  funding  from 
Getty  Research  Institute 


https://archive.org/details/comparativeexhibOOsoci 


Comparative  Exhibition 

OF 

NATIVE  AND  FOREIGN 
ART 


1904 


UNDER  THE  AUSPICES  OF  THE 

SOCIETY  OF  ART  COLLECTORS 


AT  THE  GALLERIES  OF 

THE  AMERICAN  FINE  ARTS  SOCIETY 

215  WEST  FIFTY-SEVENTH  STREET 
NEW  YORK 


Press  of  J.  J.  Little  &  Co. 
Astor  Place,  New  York 


SOCIETY  OF  ART  COLLECTORS 

558  FIFTH  AVENUE 
NEW  YORK 


Officers  and  Directors 

JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES 
President 

CHARLES  STEWART  SMITH  HENRY  B.  WILSON 

Vice  President  Treasurer 

ALEXANDER  C.  HUMPHREYS  FREDERIC  BONNER 

WILLIAM  T.  EVANS  RUSSELL  SPAULDING 

Secretary  Assistant  Secretary 

Chairman  Committee  on  American  Art 
WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


Chairman  Committee  on  Foreign  Art 
FREDERIC  BONNER 


ACKNOWLEDGMENT 


MR-  JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES, 
President,  and  the  Officers  and  Direc¬ 
tors  of  the  Society  of  Art  Collectors  hereby 
tender  their  sincere  thanks  and  assurances 
of  appreciation  to  all  those  who  have  directly 
or  indirectly  contributed  to  the  formation  of 
The  Comparative  Exhibition  of  Native 
and  Foreign  Art. 


PATRONS 


Edward  D.  Adams 
Frederick  L.  Ames,  Boston. 
John  Stanley  Ames,  Boston. 

R.  B.  Angus,  Montreal 

Gorham  Bacon 

George  F.  Baker 

Charles  T.  Barney 

Cornelius  N.  Bliss 

Walter  P.  Bliss 

Lyman  G.  Bloomingdale 

Frederic  Bonner 

George  S.  Bowdoin 

Edson  Bradley 

John  Crosby  Brown 

Dr.  Charles  Stedman  Bull 

Nicholas  Murray  Butler 

Andrew  Carnegie 

Frank  R.  Chambers 

B.  Ogden  Chisolm 

John  Claflin 

Hon.  William  A.  Clark 

Edward  H.  Coates,  Philadelphia 

Hon.  Bird  S.  Coler 

Heinrich  Conried 

Charles  T .  Cook 

John  D.  Crimmins 

Richard  J.  Cross 

W.  Bayard  Cutting 


Daniel  A.  Davis 

Robert  W.  De  Forest 

Dr.  Richard  H.  Derby 

Carll  H.  De  Silver 

George  G.  De  Witt 

Sir  Geo.  Drummond,  Montreal 

William  Butler  Duncan 

John  Elderkin 

William  T.  Evans 

Harris  C.  Fahnestock 

Isaac  D.  Fletcher 

Charles  L.  Freer,  Detroit 

W.  N.  Frew,  Pittsburg 

Dr.  William  Gardner,  Montreal 

John  Gellatly 

Richard  Watson  Gilder 

Chas.  C.  Glover,  Washington 

Charles  W.  Gould 

George  Gould 

Henry  Graves 

E.  B.  Greenshields,  Montreal 
Daniel  Guggenheim 
George  B.  M.  Harvey 
George  G.  Haven 
Henry  O.  Havemeyer 
A.  Augustus  Healy 
George  A.  Hearn 
Col.  Frank  J.  Hecker,  Detroit 


James  J,  Higginson 

Dr.  Alexander  C.  Humphreys 

Joseph  Howland  Hunt 

Richard  Howland  Hunt 

Charles  L.  Hutchinson,  Chicago 

James  H.  Hyde 

Joseph  Jefferson 

Morris  K.  Jesup 

Bradish  Johnson 

Augustus  D.  Juilliase 

Wm.  Mackay  Laffan 

Catholxna  Lambert 

Cyrus  J.  Lawrence 

Frank  R.  Lawrence 

Homer  Lee 

Thornton  K.  Lothkop,  Boston 
Hon.  Seth  Low 
Charles  H.  Ludington 
Howard  Mansfield 
Louis  Marshall 
Hon.  George  B.  McClellan 
Emerson  McMillin 
Newbqlb  Morris 
Hon.  Levi  P.  Morton 
Walter  G.  Oakman 
Ralph  H.  Plumb,  Buffalo 
Rt.  Rev.  Henry  C.  Potter 
Charles  M.  Pratt 
Frederick  B.  Pratt 
William  A.  Read 
Hon.  Whitelaw  Reid 
John  Harsen  Rhoades 
John  J.  Riker 


John  L.  Riker 
J.  Hampden  Robb 
Edward  Robinson,  Boston 
George  H.  Robinson 
W.  Emlen  Roosevelt 
James  Ross,  Montreal. 

Hon.  Elihu  Root 
William  Jay  Schieffelin 
Jacob  H.  Schiff 
W.  Watts  Sherman 
John  W.  Simpson 
Henry  T.  Sloane 
William  D.  Sloane 
Charles  Stewart  Smith 
William  E.  Strong 
Anson  Phelps  Stokes 
Lispenard  Stewart 
John  A.  Stewart 
H.  L.  Terrell 
Spencer  Trask 
Samuel  Untermyer 
Sir  William  Van  Horne, 

Montreal 

Henry  Walters,  Baltimore 
Leslie  D.  Ward 

E.  Burgess  Warren,  Philadelphia 

Samuel  D.  Warren,  Boston. 

John  R.  Waters 

Stanford  White 

James  B.  Williams 

Thomas  Williams 

Francis  Wilson 

Henry  B.  Wilson 


PATRONESSES 


Mrs.  Robert  Abbe 
Mrs.  Edward  D.  Adams 
Mrs.  Thatcher  M.  Adams 
Miss  Mary  S.  Ames,  Boston 
Mrs.  Astor 

Mrs.  John  Jacob  Astor 
Mrs.  George  F.  Baker 
Mrs.  William  Barbour 
Mrs.  D.  Newton  Barney, 

Farmington,  Conn. 
Mrs.  Edmund  L.  Baylies 
Mrs.  Charles  C.  Beaman 
Mrs.  E.  J.  Berwind 
Mrs.  Heber  R.  Bishop 
Mrs.  George  T.  Bliss 
Mrs.  George  Bliss 
Miss  Bliss 
Miss  Ida  E.  Bliss 
Mrs.  Frederic  Bonner 
Mrs.  Walston  Hill  Brown 
Mrs.  Harold  Brown,  Newport 
Mrs.  Lloyd  S.  Bryce 
Mrs.  Prescott  Hall  Butler 
Mrs.  Royal  Phelps  Carroll 
Miss  Margaret  Chanler 
Mrs.  B.  Ogden  Chisolm 
Mrs.  Henry  Clews 
Mrs.  Ogden  Codman,  Jr. 


Mrs.  W.  Bayard  Cutting 
Mrs.  Howland  Davis 
Mrs.  George  B.  De  Forest 
Mrs.  Richard  H.  Derby 
Mrs.  George  G.  De  Witt 
Mrs.  William  H.  Draper 
Mrs.  John  R.  Drexel 
Miss  Katherine  Du  Bois. 
Mrs.  John  J.  Emery 
Mrs.  William  T.  Evans 
Mrs.  Stuyvesant  Fish 
Miss  Frelinghuysen 
Mrs.  J.  L.  Gardner,  Boston 
Mrs.  John  Henry  Hammond 
Mrs.  E.  H.  Harriman 
Mrs.  John  Hay,  Washington 
Mrs.  George  A.  Hearn 
Mrs.  James  J.  Higginson 
Mrs.  Richard  Morris  Hunt 
Mrs.  Colli s  P.  Huntington 
Mrs.  James  S.  Inglis 
Mrs.  George  Inness,  Jr. 

Mrs.  Richard  Irvin 
Mrs.  Cadwalader  Jones 
Mrs.  Augustus  D.  Juilliard 
Mrs.  John  J.  Kane 
Mrs.  Delancey  Kane 
Mrs.  J.  Frederic  Kernochan 


Mrs.  David  P.  Kimball,  Boston 
Mrs.  Gustav  E.  Kissel 
Mrs.  James  Lawrence, 

Groton,  Mass. 
Mrs.  John  T.  Martin 
Mrs.  George  B.  McClellan 
Mrs.  Daniel  Mekriman,  Boston 
Mrs.  John  W.  Minturn 
Mrs.  E.  Rollins  Morse 
Mrs.  Thomas  Newcomb 
Mrs.  Herman  Oelrichs 
Mrs.  John  E.  Parsons 
Mrs.  Henry  Codman  Potter 
Mrs.  Dallas  Bache  Pratt 
Mrs.  Charles  de  Rham,  Jr. 

Mrs.  John  Harsen  Rhoades,  Jr. 
Mrs.  Douglas  Robinson 
Mrs.  Hilborne  L.  Roosevelt 
Mrs.  Charles  H.  Russell 
Mrs.  John  J.  Riker 
Mrs.  John  L.  Riker 
Mrs.  Winthrop  Sargent 
Mrs.  Barthold  Schlesinger, 

Boston 

Mrs.  J.  Montfort  Schley 
Mrs.  James  A.  Scrymser 


Mrs.  J.  Montgomery  Sears, 

Boston 

Mrs.  Elliott  F.  Shepard 
Mrs.  Horatio  N.  Slater,  Boston 
Mrs.  Hunt  Slater,  Boston 
Mrs.  William  Douglas  Sloane 
Mrs.  Charles  Stewart  Smith 
Mrs.  John  A.  Stewart 
Mrs.  I.  N.  Phelps  Stokes 
Mrs.  John  B.  Trevor 
Mrs.  Samuel  Untermyer 
Mrs.  Frederick  W.  Vanderbilt 
Mrs.  Alexander  Van  Rensselaer, 
Philadelphia. 
Mrs.  Samuel  D.  Warren,  Boston 
Miss  Julia  Chester  Wells 
Mrs.  Arthur  W'elman 
Mrs.  Stanford  White 
Miss  Grace  Wilkes 
Mrs.  Henry  B.  Wilson 
Mrs.  M.  Orme  Wilson 
Mrs.  Ichabod  T.  Williams 
Mrs.  Robert  Winthrop 
Mrs.  Frank  Spencer  Witherbee 
Mrs.  Roger  Wolcott,  Boston 


INTRODUCTION 


ABOUT  a  year  ago  a  few  gentlemen  interested 
in  art  entered  into  a  discussion  as  to  the  best 
measures  to  be  adopted  in  order  to  quicken  the  public 
appreciation  of  the  unquestionably  meritorious  work  of 
American  painters,  so  many  of  whom  have  suffered  from 
lack  of  proper  recognition.  An  impetus  was  added  when 
it  was  announced  that  Mr.  Charles  Stewart  Smith,  Chair¬ 
man  of  the  Building  Committee  of  the  Metropolitan 
Museum  of  Art,  had  declared  that  better  facilities  should 
be  furnished  by  the  Museum  for  the  exhibition  of  Ameri¬ 
can  paintings,  and,  to  this  end,  a  special  gallery  was  to 
be  provided  in  the  new  wing  about  to  be  erected. 

The  little  group  of  art  lovers  afterwards  met 
occasionally  to  talk  over  suggested  projects,  and  patriot¬ 
ically,  but  perhaps  too  boldly,  resolved  to  hold  in  the 
fall  of  the  present  year  a  Comparative  Exhibition  of 
two  hundred  paintings,  to  consist  of  an  equal  number  of 
the  best  modern  European  paintings  that  could  be  pro¬ 
cured  and  of  the  best  American  works  obtainable.  It 
was  furthermore  decided  that  the  native  and  foreign 
paintings  should  be  interspersed  or  hung  side  by  side, 
thereby  affording  for  the  first  time  on  a  large  scale  an 
opportunity  to  compare  American  with  European  paint¬ 
ings  on  even  terms. 


For  the  encouragement  of  art,  the  gentlemen  in¬ 
terested  have  formed  themselves  into  a  corporation  under 
the  title  of  “The  Society  of  Art  Collectors.” 

Portraits  as  a  rule,  and  mural  paintings  have  been 
for  obvious  reasons  excluded. 

This  Exhibition  has  been  arranged  in  no  contentious 
spirit  of  rivalry  and  competition,  for  there  are  and  have 
been  no  more  ardent  admirers  of  the  great  work  of  the 
masters  of  the  modern  schools  of  art  in  Europe  than  the 
American  artist  and  collector.  It  covers,  in  an  inade¬ 
quate  manner,  approximately  the  past  century  of  art. 
It  could  not,  tor  various  reasons,  including  limitation  of 
space,  be  made  complete.  Not  all  the  able  artists  on 
either  side  are  represented,  but  the  lists  are  sufficiently 
comprehensive  to  afford  a  full  and  fair  comparison. 
Certain  omissions,  therefore,  must  not  be  construed  as 
casting  any  reflection  on  artists  not  represented.  This 
exhibition  is  claimed  to  be  only  one  step  in  the  right 
direction  to  stimulate  the  appreciation  of  American  Art 
at  its  true  value,  and,  if  this  result  is  accomplished  the 
Society  of  Art  Collectors  will  feel  that  it  has  not  labored 
in  vain. 

The  expenses  of  the  Exhibition  have  been  under¬ 
written,  and  all  receipts,  after  payment  of  actual  ex¬ 
penses,  will  be  given  to  the  New  York  Eye  and  Ear 
Infirmary, 


CATALOGUE 


i 


LOUIS  ARTAN 
Coast  Scene 


Loaned  by 

MESSRS.  COTTIER  &  CO. 


2 

RALPH  ALBERT  BLAKELOCK 
Brook  by  Moonlight 


Loaned  by 

MR.  CATHOLINA  LAMBERT 


3 


RALPH  ALBERT  RLAKELOCK 


Sunset ,  Nevarra  Ridge 

Loaned  by 

MR,  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


4 

RALPH  ALBERT  BLAKELOCK 
Moonlight 

Loaned  by 
THE  OWNER 


5 

GEORGE  H.  BOGERT 
Sea  and  Rain 


Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


6 


LOUIS  EUGENE  BOUDIN 

1824-1 898 


Le  Port  de  Prattville,  Marie  Basse 


Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


7 

LOUIS  EUGENE  BOUDIN 

1 824-1898 


Marine,  Sur  la  Meuse 


Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  STEWART  SMITH 


8 

ROBERT  B.  BRANDEGEE 
Miss  Sarah  Porter 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  D.  NEWTON  BARNEY 


JOHN  LEWIS  BROWN 

1829-1890. 

Horses’  Heads 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  BARTHOLD  SCHLESINGER 


10 

GEORGE  DE  FOREST  BRUSH 
Mother  and  Child 

Loaned  by 

MR.  J.  MONTGOMERY  SEARS 


II 

WILLIAM  GEDNEY  BUNCE 
Venice 

Loaned  by 

MR.  GEORGE  H.  ROBINSON 


12 


WILLIAM  GEDNEY  BUNCE 


Sunset ,  San  Giorgio 


Loaned  by 

WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


* 


I3 

WILLIAM  GEDNEY  BUNCE 
Morning  in  V mice 


Loaned  by 
THE  OWNER 


14 

WILLIAM  M.  CHASE 


An  English  God 


Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  M.  CHASE 


J5 


J.  B.  C.  COROT 

1796-1875 

Reclining  Woman ,  Tiger  Skin 

Loaned  by 

HON.  WILLIAM  A.  CLARK 


l6 

J.  B.  C.  COROT 

1796-1875 

La  Cbarrette 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  JOHN  T.  MARTIN 


*7 

J.  B.  C.  COROT 

1796-1875 

Cavalier  sur  une  Route 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  B.  WILSON 


J.  B.  C.  COROT 

1796-1875 

Le  Lac  Nemi 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  THOMAS  NEWCOMB 


1 9 

J.  B.  C.  COROT 

1796-1875 


Summer  Day 


Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES  ’ 


20 

GUSTAVE  COURBET 

1819-1878 


Taureau  et  Genisse 


Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


21 


THOMAS  COUTURE 

1815-1879 

Le  Petit  Gill 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  STEWART  SMITH 


22 


CHARLES  FRANCOIS  DAUBIGNY 

1817-1878 


Evening  on  the  River 

Loaned  by 

HON.  WILLIAM  A.  CLARK 


CHARLES  FRANCOIS  DAUBIGNY 

1817-1878 

Sunset  on  the  Oise 

Loaned  by 

MR.  SAMUEL  UNTERMYER 


24 


CHARLES  FRANCOIS  DAUBIGNY 
1817-1878 


Sheepfold — Sundown 


Loaned  by 

MISS  MARY  S.  AMES 


25 

CHARLES  FRANCOIS  DAUBIGNY 
1817-1878 


Landscape 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  BARTHOLD  SCHLESINGER 


26 

CHARLES  FRANCOIS  DAUBIGNY 
1817-1878 

The  Apple  Orchard 


Loaned  by 
MR.  R.  B.  ANGUS 


27 


CHARLES  FRANCOIS  DAUBIGNY 

1817-1878 


Hayfield 

Loaned  by 

SIR  WILLIAM  VAN  HORNE 


28 

CHARLES  FRANCOIS  DAUBIGNY 

1817-1878 

Evening 

Loaned  by 

MR  CARLL  H.  DE  SILVER 


29 

ARTHUR  B.  DAVIES 
Two  Step 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  DANIEL  MERRIMAN 


3° 


CHARLES  H.  DAVIS 


Summer 


Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


3* 

CHARLES  H.  DAVIS 
Clouds  and  Hills 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES 


32 

ALEXANDRE  GABRIEL  DECAMPS 
1803-1860 

The  Ambuscade 


Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  B.  WILSON 


33 

ALEXANDRE  GABRIEL  DECAMPS 

i 803-1 860 


The  Turkish  Butcher  Shop 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 


34 

EDGAR  DEGAS 
Musiciens  a  /’  Orchestre 


Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


35 

EDGAR  DEGAS 
Chevaux  de  Course 

Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


EUGENE  DELACROIX 

1799-1863 

Spring 


Loaned  by 

MESSRS.  COTTIER  &  CO. 


37 

EUGENE  DELACROIX 

1799-1863 


Summer 


Loaned  by 

MESSRS.  COTTIER  &  CO, 


EUGENE  DELACROIX 

1799-1863 


Autumn 


Loaned  by 

MESSRS.  COTTIER  &  CO. 


39 

EUGENE  DELACROIX 

1799-1863 

Winter 

Loaned  by 

MESSRS.  COTTIER  &  CO. 


40 

EUGENE  DELACROIX 

1799-1863 


The  Wounded  Tiger 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 


41 

EUGENE  DELACROIX 

1799-1863 

Christ  on  the  Lake  of  Genesareth 


Loaned  by 

SIR  WILLIAM  VAN  HORNE 


42 


LOUIS  PAUL  DESSAR 


A  Hilltop 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES 


43 

THOMAS  W.  DEWING 


Slimmer 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JAMES  B.  WILLIAMS 


44 

THOMAS  W.  DEWING 

' The  White  Carnation 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


45 

THOMAS  W.  DEWING 
Head  of  a  Girl 

Loaned  fay 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


d6 

THOMAS  W.  DEWING 
The  Spinet 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  GELLATLY 


Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  GELLATLY 


47 

THOMAS  W.  DEWING 
Reading 


48 

N.  V.  DIAZ 

i 808-1876 

Les  Bohemiens 

Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


49 

N.  V.  DIAZ 

1 808-1 876 

The  Lovers 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


50 

N.  V.  DIAZ 

1 808-1876 


Sun  Worshippers 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


51 


N.  V.  DIAZ 

1808-1876 

In  the  Forest 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 

52 

N.  V.  DIAZ 

1808-1876 

Edge  of  the  Forest ,  October 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 

53 

N.  V.  DIAZ 

1808-1876 

Summer 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 


54 

JULES  DUPRE 

1812-1889 


Cattle,  La?idscape 


Loaned  by 

HON.  WILLIAM  A.  CLARK 


55 

JULES  DUPRfi 

1812-1889 


Going  to  Pasture 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 

56 

JULES  DUPRE 

1812-1889 

The  Cottage 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 


57 


WYATT  EATON 

1849-1896 

Reverie 

Loaned  by 

MR.  FREDERICK  B.  PRATT 


5^ 

WYATT  EATON 

1849-1896 

Ariadne 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


59 

WYATT  EATON 

1849-1896 

La  CJgale 


Loaned  by 

COL.  FRANK  J.  HECKER 


6o 


BENJAMIN  R.  FITZ 

1855-1891 

The  Reflection 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


6l 

EUGENE  FROMENTIN 

1820-1876 

The  Falconer 

Loaned  by 

MR.  SAMUEL  UNTERMYER 


62 

EUGENE FROMENTIN 

1820-1876 

Marchands  de  Chevaux  Arabes 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  COLLIS  P.  HUNTING  PON 


6 3 

GEORGE  FULLER 

1822-1884 


Winifred  Dysart 

Loaned  by 

MR.  J.  MONTGOMERY  SEARS 


64 

GEORGE  FULLER 

1822-1884 

The  Quadroon 

Loaned  by 

MR.  GEORGE  A.  HEARN 


GEORGE  FULLER 

1822-1884 


A  Romany  Girl 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


66 


GEORGE  FULLER 

1822=1884 

Girl  with  Turkeys 

Loaned  by 

DR.  ALEXANDER  C.  HUMPHREYS 


6? 

GEORGE  FULLER 

1822-1884 


Led  through  the  Meadow 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


68 

JEAN  LOUIS  GERICAULT 

1791=1824 

Francois  Ier 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  STEWART  SMITH 


69 

HENRI  HARPIGNIES 


Night 

Loaned  by 

MR.  C.  W.  KRAUSHAAR 


70 

CHILDE  HASSAM 
The  Arno 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  GELLATLY 


?! 

WINSLOW  HOMER 
Maine  Coast 

Loaned  by 

MR.  GEORGE  A.  HEARN 


72 


WINSLOW  HOMER 

“AWs  Weir 

Loaned  by 

THE  BOSTON  MUSEUM  OF  FINE  ARTS 


73 

WINSLOW  HOMER 


Undertow 


Loaned  by 

MR.  EDWARD  D.  ADAMS 


74 

WINSLOW  HOMER 


The  Gale 


Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES 


75- 

WINSLOW  HOMER 


High  Cliff \  Coast  of  Maine 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


?6 

WILLIAM  MORRIS  HUNT 

1824-1879 

Mother  and  C hild 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  RICHARD  MORRIS  HUNT 


77 

WILLIAM  MORRIS  HUNT 

1824-1879 

The  Bathers 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  HUNT  SLATER,  TRUSTEE 


WILLIAM  MORRIS  HUNT 

1824-1879 


Spouting  Whale 


Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


7P 

WILLIAM  MORRIS  HUNT 

1824-1879 

The  Jewess 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  HORATIO  N.  SLATER 


80 


GEORGE  INNESS 

1825-1 894 

The  W ood  Gatherers 

Loaned  by 

MR.  GEORGE  A.  HEARN 


8 1 

GEORGE  INNESS 

1825--1894 

Sundown 


Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


82 

GEORGE  INNESS 

1825-1894 

A  Cloudy  Day 

Loaned  by 

MR.  GEORGE  INNESS,  Jr. 


GEORGE  INNESS 

1825-1894 

Coast  of  Cornwall 


Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  D.  CRIMMINS 


84 

GEORGE  INNESS 
1825-1894 

Sunset  on  the  Passaic 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  R.  WATERS 


<?5 

GEORGE  INNESS,  Jr. 

In  the  Surf 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  GEORGE  INNESS,  Jr. 


£<5 

JEAN  BAPTISTE  ISABEY 
1767-1855 

Francis  /,  King  of  France 


Loaned  by 

MR.  EDSON  BRADLEY 


JOZEF  ISRAELS 
The  Fisherman  s  Cottage 

Loaned  by 

SIR  GEORGE  DRUMMOND 


88 

CHARLES  E.  JACQUE 
Interior  of  Stable 

Loaned  by 

MESSRS.  ARTHUR  TOOTH  &  SONS 


89 

JOHAN  BARTHOLD  JONGKIND 

I822-I89I 

Boris  de  /’  Oise 

Loaned  by 

SIR  GEORGE  DRUMMOND 


9° 


JOHAN  BARTHOLD  JONGKIND 
i 822-1 891 


Vue  Generate  de  Horfeur 


Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


FREDERICK  W.  KOST 
The  Driftwood  Gatherer 

Loaned  by 

MR.  LYMAN  G.  BLOOMINGDALE 


92 

JOHN  LA  FARGE 
Visit  of  Nicodemus  to  Christ 


Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


93 


JOHN  LA  FARGE 
Autumn 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  GELLATLY 


94 

JOHN  LA  FARGE 
Paradise  Valley 

Loaned  by 

MR.  THORNTON  K.  LOTHROP 


SIR  THOMAS  LAWRENCE 

1769-1830 

Nature 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  COLLIS  P.  HUNTINGTON 


96 

JAKOB  MARIS 

The  Arrival  of  the  Fishing  Boat 

Loaned  by 

DR.  WILLIAM  GARDNER 


97 

JAKOB  MARIS 
Loading  the  Barge 

Loaned  by 

MR.  FRANCIS  WILSON 


JAKOB  MARIS 
A  Tiller  of  the  Soil 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABODT.  WILLIAMS 


99 

JAKOB  MARIS 
Amsterdam 


Loaned  by 
MRS.  BARTHOLD 


SCHLESINGER 


IOO 

WILLELM  MARIS 
Landscape  and  Cattle 

Loaned  by 

MR.  FRANCIS  WILSON 


IOI 

HOMER  D.  MARTIN 

1836-1897 

Westchester  Hills 

Loaned  by 

MR.  DANIEL  GUGGENHEIM 


102 


HOMER  D.  MARTIN 

1836-1897 

Old  Church  in  Normandy 

Loaned  by 

MR.  SAMUEL  UNTERMYER 


103 

HOMER  D.  MARTIN 

1836-1897 

Adirondack  Scenery 

Loaned  by 

MR.  SAMUEL  UNTERMYER 


IO4 

HOMER  D.  MARTIN 

1836-1897 

The  Mussel  Gatherers 


Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


HOMER  D.  MARTIN 

1836-1897 

Near  Newport 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


106 

HOMER  D.  MARTIN 

1836-1897 

Old  Normandy  Bridge 

Loaned  by 

DR.  ALEXANDER  C.  HUMPHREYS 


10/ 

ANTON  MAUVE 

1838-1888 

Plowing 


Loaned  by 

MR.  JOSEPH  JEFFERSON 


io8 


ANTON  MAUVE 

1838-1888 


Pets  of  the  Milkmaid 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


iog 

GEORGES  MICHEL 

1763-1843 


Montmartre 


Loaned  by 

MR.  CATHOLINA  LAMBERT 


no 


J.  F.  MILLET 

181 4-1875 

The  Sheep  Shearers 


Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 


Ill 


J.  F.  MILLET 

1814-1875 

Quarriers 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


1 12 

J.  F.  MILLET 

1814-1875 

The  Water  Carrier 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  HENRY  CODMAN  POTTER 


II3 

J.  F.  MILLET 

1814-1875 

Gleaners 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  HENRY  CODMAN  POTTER 


ROBERT  C.  MINOR 

1840-1904 

The  Close  of  Day 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  A.  READ 


IT5 

ROBERT  C.  MINOR 

1840-1904 

Evening 


Loaned  by 

MR.  HOMER  LEE 


1/6 


CLAUDE  MONET 
La  Seine  a  Lavacour 


Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


ADOLPHE  MONTICELLI 

1824-1886 

Adoration  of  the  Magii 

Loaned  by 

SIR  WILLIAM  VAN  HORNE 


Il8 

ADOLPHE  MONTICELLI 

1824-1886 

Landscape 

Loaned  by 

SIR  WILLIAM  VAN  HORNE 


//<? 

ADOLPHE  MONTICELLI 

1824-1886 

A  Summer  s  Day  Idyll 


Loaned  by 
MR.  R.  B.  ANGUS 


120 


ADOLPHE  MONTICELL1 

1824-1886 

Landscape  with  Figures 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


12 1 


ADOLPHE  MONTICELLI 

1824-1886 


Dolce  far  Niente 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


122 

ADOLPHE  MONTICELLI 

1824-1886 

Farmyard 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


123 

ADOLPHE  MONTICELLI 

1824-X886 


Bon  Quixote  and  Sambo  Panza  entering 
the  Garden  of  the  Duchess 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  L.  TERRELL 


124 

J.  FRANCIS  MURPHY 
A  Hillside  Farm 

Loaned  by 
VHE  OWNER 


Loaned  by 

HON.  BIRD  S.  COLER 


125 

j.  FRANCIS  MURPHY 
Meadowland 


126 


J.  FRANCIS  MURPHY 
Approach  to  an  Old  Farm 

Loaned  by 

DR.  ALEXANDER  C.  HUMPHREYS 


I2J 

J.  FRANCIS  MURPHY 
A  Grey  Day 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES 


128 

ALBERT  NEUHUYS 
Mother  and  Child 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOSEPH  JEFFERSON 


ALBERT  NEIJHUYS 
Young  Mother 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  C.  COTTON 


130 

ALBERT  NEUHUYS 
Mending  the  Sacque 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  C.  COTTON 


*3* 

HENRY  W.  RANGER 
Noank 

Loaned  by 
THE  OWNER 


HENRY  W.  RANGER 


Spring  Woods 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES 


^33 

HENRY  W.  RANGER 
Pasture  by  Moonlight 

Loaned  by 
THE  OWNER 


^34 

HENRY  W.  RANGER 


Cornfield 


Loaned  by 
THE  OWNER 


*35 

HENRI  REGNAULT 
1843-1871 


Horses  of  Achilles 

Loaned  by 

MR.  H.  L.  TERRELL 


I36 

PIERRE  AUGUSTE  RENOIR 


Le  Dejeuner 

Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


137 

THEODULE  RIBOT 

1823-1891 

Studio  of  the  Artist 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


THEODULE  RIBOT 

1823-1891 

Mignonne  (1864) 


Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


*39 

THEODULE  RIBOT 

1823-1891 

La  Recureuse 

Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


140 

THEODORE  ROBINSON 

1852-1896 

Twachtmari  s  House 


Loaned  by 

DR.  ALEXANDER  C.  HUMPHREYS 


THEODORE  ROBINSON 

1852-1896 

La  Lebdcle 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  GELLATLY 


142 

THEO.  ROUSSEAU 
1812-1867 

The  Great  Oaks  of  Bas  Bre'au 

Loaned  by 

SIR  WILLIAM  VAN  HORNE 


H3 

THEO.  ROUSSEAU 
1812-1867 

Morning  on  the  River  Oise 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 


*44 

FERDINAND  ROYBET 


Abduction  of  Rebecca 


Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


f45 

ALBERT  P.  RYDER 


Siegfried 


Loaned  by 

SIR  WILLIAM  VAN  HORNE 


146 

ALBERT  P.  RYDER 
Custance 

Loaned  by 

SIR  WILLIAM  VAN  HORNE 


*47 

ALBERT  P.  RYDER 


The  Flying  Dutchman 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  GELLATLY 


iy8 

WILLIAM  SARTAIN 
Arab  School  in  Algiers 

Loaned  by 

DR.  ALEXANDER  C.  HUMPHREYS 


I4.9 

WILLIAM  SARTAIN 
Sand  Dunes  of  Buzzard’s  Bay 


Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  MACBETH 


ALFRED  SISLEY 

i 840—1899 

Hiver  a  Marly 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CATHOLINA  LAMBERT 


151 

ALFRED  SISLEY 

1840-1899 

La  Terrasse  a  Saint  Germain 

Loaned  by 

M.  DURAND-RUEL 


T52 

ABBOTT  H.  THAYER 

Caritas 


Loaned  by 

THE  BOSTON  MUSEUM  OF  FINE  ARTS 


J53 


ABBOTT  H.  THAYER 


Seated  Figure 

Loaned  by 

COL.  FRANK  J.  HECKER 


154 

ABBOTT  H.  THAYER 
Head 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


155 

ABBOTT  H.  THAYER 
A  Virgin  Enthroned 

Loaned  by 

MR.  J.  MONTGOMERY  SEARS 


75^ 

CONSTANT  TROYON 

1810-1865 

Descent  of  the  Cows 

Loaned  by 
MR.  JAMES  ROSS 


157 

CONSTANT  TROYON 

1810-1865 


Marine 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  ICHABOD  T.  WILLIAMS 


j58 

CONSTANT  TROYON 

1810-1865 

George  Sand 

Loaned  by 

SIR  WILLIAM  VAN  HORNE 


CONSTANT  TROYON 

1810-1865 

Normandy  Cows 

Loaned  by 

MR.  HENRY  GRAVES 


l60 

CONSTANT  TROYON 

1810-1865 

Chien  d'  Arret 

Loaned  by 

MISS  MARY  S.  AMES 


l6l 

DWIGHT  W.  TRYON 
Daybreak-May 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


162 


DWIGHT  W.  TRYON 


Daybreak 


Loaned  by 

MR  D.  J.  MORRISON 


163 

DWIGHT  W.  TRYON 


New  England  Hills 


Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


164 

DWIGHT  W.  TRYON 
The  Farm ,  October  Night 


Loaned  by 

COL.  FRANK  J.  HECKER 


J.  M.  W.  TURNER 
1775-1851 

Venice ,  the  Dogana  and  Santa  Maria  della  Salute 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JAMES  ROSS 


l66 

JOHN  H.  TWACHTMAN 

1853-1902 

The  Torrent 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


l6 / 

JOHN  H.  TWACHTMAN 

1853-1902 

The  Hemlock  Pool 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  GELLATLY 


i68 


HORATIO  WALKER 


The  Harrower 


Loaned  by 

MR.  GEORGE  A.  HEARN 


l6() 

HORATIO  WALKER 


Moonrise — A  Canadian  Pastoral 

Loaned  by 

DR.  ALEXANDER  C.  HUMPHREYS 


IJO 

HORATIO  WALKER 


Oxen  Drinking 


Loaned  by 

MR.  NEWMAN  E.  MONTROSS 


I7I 

J.  ALDEN  WEIR 
The  Green  Bodice 

Loaned  by 

MR.  GEORGE  A.  HEARN 


172 

J.  ALDEN  WEIR 
Lengthening  Shadows 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JAMES  S.  INGLIS 


173 

JAN  WEISSENRRUCH 
1822—1880 

Beached 

Loaned  by 

MR.  FRANCIS  WILSON 


*74 

JAN  WEISSENBRUCH 
1822-1880 

Low-Tide ,  Zeeland 

Loaned  by 

MR.  E.  B.  GREENSHIELDS 


175 


J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 

1834-1903 


Arrangement  in  Black  and  White  Mo.  I 


Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


I76 

J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 

1834-1903 

Nocturne — Blue  and  Silver — Bognor 


Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


177 

J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 

1834-1903 

Nocturne— Blue  and  Silver — Battersea  Reach 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


178 

J,  McNEILL  WHISTLER 
1834-1903 

The  Little  Blue  and  Gold  Girl 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


179 

J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 
1834-1903 

Symphony  in  Grey — Early  Morning— Thames 


Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


i8o 

J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 

1834-1903 


Rose  and  Gold — The  Little  Lady  Sophie  of  Soho 


Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


l8l 

J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 

1834-1903 

The  Little  Red  Glove 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CHARLES  L.  FREER 


l82 

J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 

1834-1903 

Harmony  in  Green  and  Rose — -The  Music  Room 


Loaned  by 

COL.  FRANK  J.  HECKER 


J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 

1834-1903 

Symphony  in  Gray  and  Green — The  Ocean 

Loaned  by 

MR,  RICHARD  A.  CANFIELD 


184 

J.  McNEILL  WHISTLER 

1834-1903 

Nocturne  in  Black  and  Gold— CF he  Falling  Rocket 

Loaned  by 

MRS.  SAMUEL  UNTERM YER 


*85 

F.  BALLARD  WILLIAMS 
Rapids  of  Rockaway  River ,  N.  J. 


Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES 


i86 


ALEXANDER  H.  WYANT 

1836-1892  v 

In  the  Adirondacks 

Loaned  by 

MR.  GEORGE  A.  HEARN 


187 


ALEXANDER  H.  WYANT 

1836-1892 


Any  Man's  Land 


Loaned  by 

MR.  D.  J.  MORRISON 


188 

ALEXANDER  H.  WYANT 

1836-1892 

Connecticut  Valley 


Loaned  by 

MR.  SAMUEL  UNTERMYER 


ALEXANDER  H.  WYANT 

1836-1892 

Keene  Valley 

Loaned  by 

MR.  CARLL  H.  DE  SILVER 


igO 

ALEXANDER  H.  WYANT 

1836-1892 

Housatonic  V alley 

Loaned  by 

MR.  WILLIAM  T.  EVANS 


ALEXANDER  H.  WYANT 

1836-1892 

A  Cloudy  Day— Keene  V alley 

Loaned  by 

COL.  FRANK  J.  HECKER 


ADDENDUM 


192 

CHARLES  MELVILLE  DEWEY 
Return  of  the  Hay  Boat 

Loaned  by 

MR.  JOHN  HARSEN  RHOADES 


WbJ  SLOANE 

NEW  YORK 


INTERIOR  DECORATION 
CLASSIC  FURNITURE 
UPHOLSTERY  FABRICS 
CARPETINGS  AND 
RARE  ORIENTAL  RUGS 


B  ROADWAY  AND 
NINETEENTH  ST. 


THE  GORHAM 
COMPANY 

begs  to  announce  to  its  patrons  that 
preparations  for  the  Holiday  Season 
have  been  completed  and  to  suggest 
the  desirability  of  making  contem¬ 
plated  purchases  at  the  earliest 
possible  date  to  insure  not  only  an 
unbroken  assortment  from  which 
to  select,  but  to  permit  of  sufficient 
time  to  properly  carry  out  pur¬ 
chasers’  wishes  as  to  engraving  and 
shipping.  Articles  bought  at  the 
present  time  will  be  held  for  delivery 
on  such  dates  as  buyers  may  desire. 


THE  GORHAM  COMPANY 

SILVERSMITHS  AND  GOLDSMITHS 
BROADWAY  AT  NINETEEENTH  STREET 


ESTABLISHED  1846 

M.  Knoedler  &  Co. 

invite  attention  to  their 
carefully  selected  collection  of 

PAINTINGS 

AND  WATER  COLORS  OF  VARIOUS  SCHOOLS 

Old  English  Mezzotints 
and  Colored  Sporting  Prints 

355  FIFTH  AVENUE 

(Comer  34th  Street) 

NEW  YORK 

LONDON,  13  Old  Bond  Street 
PARIS,  23  Place  Vendome 


The  watching  and  guarding  of  the  valuable  paintings 

of  the  COMPARATIVE  EXHIBITION  is 

done  day  and  night  by  the  uniformed  patrolmen  of  the 

HOLMES 

Electric  Protective  Company 


ELECTRICITY 

the  best  PROTECTION  against  burglars 

HOW  DO  YOU  LEAVE  YOUR 
HOUSE  DURING  THE  SUMMER? 

INVESTIGATE 

the  merits  of  the  Holmes  System  of 
Summer  Protection  Against  Burglary. 

IT  IS  THE  MOST  RELIABLE 

and  inexpensive  way  to  have  your 
house  cared  for  during  your  absence 
in  the  summer. 

The  Holmes  System  of  Electric  Protection  is  a 
Watchman  on  duty  at  all  hours,  day  and  night, 
Sundays  and  Holidays.  Hundreds  of  your  friends 
and  neighbors  have  used  our  system  for  years. 


Executive  Offices ,  l6  CoRTLANDT  St.,NeW  YORK 


Paintings  by 
American  Artists 

Choice  Examples  Always  on  View 

MACBETH  GALLERY 

237  FIFTH  AVENUE 


TYSON  &  BRO., 

Theatre  Ticket  Office 

HOTEL  MANHATTAN 

Tickets  for  the  Comparative  Exhibition 
ON  SALE 


Fishel,  Adler  &  Schwartz 

313  FIFTH  AVENIJE  (near  32nd  Street) 

IMPORTERS  AND  DEALERS 
in  high-class  modern  Oil  Paintings 
and  Water  Color  Drawings 

PUBLISHERS  AND  IMPORTERS 

of  Etchings,  Engravings,  Etc. 

Many  Novelties  Suitable  for  Holiday  and  Wedding  Gifts 

ARTISTIC  FRAMING  A  SPECIALTY 

CROUCH  & 
FITZGERALD 

Handsomest  .  Lightest 
Best  Luggage 

723  SIXTH  AVE.  below  42c!  Street 
1 61  BROADWAY  below  Cortlandt  St. 
688  BROADWAY  below  4th  Street 
NEW  YORK 

F.  W.  DEVOE  &  CO. 

m-*—"  4  Artists' 


C.  W.  KRAUSHAAR 

Art  Galleries 

Carefully  Selected  Oil  Paintings  by 
Corot,  Charles  Jacque,  Fantin  La- 
tour,  Harpignies,  Henner,  Israels, 
Weissenbruch,  William  Maris,  Th. 

De  Bock,  E.  Pieters,  Ziem,  Ser 
Meulen,  Bail  Joseph,  Griitzner, 
Boudin,  Jongkind  and  Others. 


260  Fifth  Ave.,  bet.  28th  and  29th  Sts. 


TYSON  &  CO. 

Theatre  Ticket  Offices 


IN  ALL  THE  LEADING 
HOTELS  AND  RESTAURANTS 

Tickets  for  the  Comparative  Exhibition 
ON  SALE 


LincolnTrust  Company 

MADISON  SQUARE,  NEW  YORK 


TRANSACTS  A  GENERAL  FIDUCIARY 
AND  BANKING  BUSINESS 


Total  Resources  Exceed  $12,000,000 


OFFICERS 


Henry  R.  Wilson  .  President  I  Robert  C.  Lewis  .  Treasurer 
Frank  Tilford  .  Vice-Pres.  William  Darrow,  Jr.  .  Sec’y 
Owen  Ward  .  .  2d  Vice-Pres.  |  E.  C.  Wilson  .  Asst.  Secretary 

EXECUTIVE  COMMITTEE 

Frank  Tilford  B.  Aymar  Sands  Samuel  D.  Styles 

Clarence  H.  Kelsey  J.  Harsen  Rhoades  John  B.  Dennis 

William  Salomon  George  C.  Clark  Henry  R.  Wilson 

DIRECTORS 

George  C.  Boldt . Pres.  Waldorf-Astoria  Hotel  Co. 

George  C.  Clark  , . Clark,  Dodge  &  Co.,  Bankers 

John  B.  Dennis . Blair  &  Co.,  Bankers 

Robert  E.  Dowling . .  Real  Estate 

Charles  S.  Fairchild  .  .  Chairman  N.  Y.  Security  &  Trust  Co. 
Robert  M.  Gallaway  ....  Pres.  Merchants  National  Bank 
Harrison  E.  Gawtry . Pres.  Consolidated  Gas  Co. 

John  R.  Hegeman . Pres.  Metropolitan  Life  Ins.  Co. 

ohn  D.  Hicks . Trustee  Bowery  Savings  Bank 

Charles  F.  Hoffman . Hoffman  Estate 

Edward  Holbrook . Pres.  Gorham  Manufacturing  Co. 

Abram  M.  Hyatt . .  Retired 

Bradish  Johnson . Bradish  Johnson  Estate 

Clarence  H.  Kelsey  .  .  .  Pres.  Title  Guarantee  &  Trust  Co. 

William  C.  Lane . Pres.  Standard  Trust  Co. 

Morton  F.  Plant . . . Capitalist 

J.  Harsen  Rhoades . Pres.  Greenwich  Savings  Bank 

Douglas  Robinson . Real  Estate 

James  I.  Raymond . A.  A.  Vantine  <fe  Co. 

William  Salomon . Wm.  Salomon  &  Co.,  Bankers 

B.  Aymar  Sands . Bowers  &  Sands,  Lawyers 

Louis  Stern . Stern  Brothers,  Dry  Goods 

William  C.  Sturges  ....  Pres.  Seamen’s  Inst,  for  Savings 

Samuel  D.  Styles . Pres.  North  River  Savings  Bank 

Frank  Tilford . Park  &  Tilford 

Archibald  Turner . Pres.  Franklin  Savings  Bank 

Henry  R.  Wilson . President 

William  G.  Park . Pittsburg,  Pa. 

William  Felsinger . Pres.  New  York  Savings  Bank 


I 

V 

f 

r 


) 


i 


09-  B32&43 


GETTY  CENTER  LIBRARY 

3  3125  00832  8490 


